I like it, but how would it generate revenue?

You don't like Citysearch?

Isn't this like craigslist?

its not been done in the manner I envision. Craigslist has a horrible interface. Citysearch is overwhelming. This focuses on one city and revenue is generated by the businesses being listed, classifieds, tourism listings, events, etc...

The problem with this idea (and many similar) is that you are basically saying you will do something that has done before, but better. Unfortunately information about how it will be better is not provided. How will you make it better?

Agree with truebeliever. The focus should be a new idea, not a bad status quo...

We already have this in Calgary. 311.

This has been done poorly a hundred times over, and moderately well for a few cities by select sites....

When ever I see something that is done "wrong", I have learned to step back and ask why? Perhaps the reason why other city portals aren't some of the slickest sites on the web is because there is a lack of resources. And perhaps there is a lack of resources because the current operating model does not generate enough revenue.

So inline with the comments above, if you can't change the operating model you will be in the same situation, fighting a losing battle. I don't think not having enough content is the problem that needs to be solved. You need to figure WHY there isn't enough content. Then you are fixing problems and not just hitting it with a bigger hammer.

To use a comparison, a car with engine problems does not run better with a body kit, new emblems, and a new paint job. If you want it better you have to get under the hood and fix the "hard" problems.

phone book online. Been done.

Although Craigslist has a horrible interface, they have a huge userbase that can not be overlooked so they are doing something right.

I think these type of services seem to work at a regional level. Meaning if you put one together for NYC and then started expanding it. I don't recall the name, but there is a web2.0 one of these in the Virginia/DC area you may want to try and research.

Either way I think the key to success here is make it work on a regional basis like craigslist did and the other regional companies are doing, and then expand it.

You WILL have to differentiate yourself to make this work and I don't think you are giving us enough info on this to understand your full concept.

It's been done before, like citysearch and craigslist. I also think Google will soon enter this area of search combined with their maps service.

done and gone?....

revived and survive!