Hey all,
Thank you for your amazing contributions to the IdeaWarz over the last couple weeks. There are now over 1000 of your wacky, brilliant, crazy, and borderless thoughts duking it out as we speak.
I love scanning the web every night and seeing all your link promotes. I click on them. I read them. I feel I already know many of you through your ideas and blogs. Some of you are truly creative and talented.
In at least one case so far, we have had someone demonstrate how the link promote could be abused in the ranking algorithm. That’s cool. We always knew the opportunity was there for people to artificially sweeten their idea, but were curious to see how many actually would. I am proud to say very few have.
In one case of idea rank gaming, the inventor was kind enough to volunteer the removal of their idea, after they proved it could be done. We didn’t really need the proof, but we appreciated this member’s gesture of volunteering to remove his idea from the board.
The response by many of you so far has re-enforced our feeling that people are inherently trustworthy. People didn’t suddenly start pumping their stat’s through fake link promotes. People left comments on ideas when they saw inappropriate behavior. Some (Julius) even reminded us of the importance of not prematurely jumping to conclusions when we see an idea with a high link promote.
Know that we spend a lot of time looking at how ideas are ranking, and don’t limit ourselves to just the top ten. IdeaWarz is a tool– but we don’t follow it blindly or systematically.
When considering ideas for upcoming market tests we look at all ideas. We look for trends (up and down). And it’s pretty easy to separate those ideas that are rising on their own merit from those that are not.